The Old Fashioned

The Old Fashioned is a celebrated American restaurant and bar & grill nestled in the heart of Madison, Wisconsin, just steps away from the State Capitol. This iconic venue pays rich homage to classic Wisconsin flavors with a vibrant, welcoming atmosphere that perfectly balances old-school supper club charm and contemporary dining energy.

At The Old Fashioned, every dish is a tribute to the state's culinary heritage, expertly prepared to deliver comforting and crave-worthy tastes. The menu bursts with staple Wisconsin delights such as the legendary Wisconsin Cheese Curds, prized for their crispy golden exterior and gooey, melt-in-your-mouth interior, often paired with a zesty Tiger sauce that elevates the experience to unparalleled levels of indulgence. The Fish Fry Combo and Walleye Sandwich showcase fresh, flaky fish battered and fried to perfection, a must-try for lovers of classic Midwestern fare.

Burgers and sandwiches here are no afterthought—they’re hearty and crafted with care. The Old Fashioned House Burger offers a juicy, perfectly grilled patty with all the fixings, while the Wells Farm Patty Melt and the spicy options bring bold, savory flavors that linger delightfully on the palate. If you prefer sandwiches, the Wisconsin Brat with its Grand Champion Miesfeld’s bratwurst, raw onions, and Dijon-style Düsseldorf mustard on a buttered roll is a local favorite that doesn’t disappoint.

Complement your meal with an expertly mixed cocktail—of course, the Old Fashioned itself is the star of the bar. Guests rave about the signature versions, such as the cherry-sweetened take with Korbel cherry bounce, which adds a smooth, luscious twist to this classic drink. Local beers including Schlitz on draft and specialty pours like the #50 1895 Bock provide excellent choices for the beer enthusiast looking to savor regional brews.

The atmosphere at The Old Fashioned is warm and inviting, echoing the spirit of a traditional supper club with its cozy interior and friendly, attentive service. Whether you’re grabbing a casual lunch, enjoying a lively night out, or celebrating a special occasion upstairs in their private event space, the venue adapts effortlessly while continuing to impress guests with both food and hospitality.

Customer experiences mirror the restaurant's charm and consistency. Several patrons highlight the unbeatable quality of the cheese curds and the depth of flavor in classic dishes like the Wisconsin Beer Cheese Soup and seasonal sandwiches. Many appreciate the staff's attentiveness and the communal, friendly vibe that welcomes everyone. One reviewer fondly recalled the birthday tradition of “birthday pickles,” a quirky and fun nod to local culture, though admittedly, a beer might be even better to mark the occasion!

The Old Fashioned isn’t just a meal; it’s an embrace of Madison’s culinary soul. For anyone craving authentic Wisconsin comfort food served with skill, heart, and a bit of flair, this restaurant is an absolute must-visit.