The Old Fashioned Menu

The Old Fashioned is a Madison staple, blending classic American flavors with Wisconsin’s rich culinary heritage. Located just steps from the Capitol, this bar and grill offers hearty dishes that celebrate local favorites like Wisconsin Cheese Curds—crispy, perfectly golden, and served with their signature Tiger sauce—and the iconic Old Fashioned cocktail, crafted here with a sweet cherry twist. Their house burger and fish fry combo stand out, satisfying cravings with bold, comforting flavors. Brunch options such as the Double Vegetable Benedict showcase fresh, seasonal ingredients, while the Wisconsin Beer Cheese Soup and Mac & Cheese embrace creamy indulgence. The menu balances tradition and innovation, with offerings like the Pork Schnitzel featuring braised cabbage and Hot German Potato Salad, adding a European touch. Paired with a solid selection of local brews and carefully curated wines, The Old Fashioned delivers a warm, inviting experience that echoes the community spirit of Madison. This spot truly elevates Midwestern comfort food with every bite.